11. Keeping The Junk Out

Open the settings →

What You Are Actually Up Against

A public form is a public form. The address is on your website, or on a leaflet, or in a QR code on a wall, and anybody who finds it can post to it. Most of what arrives uninvited is not a person at all: it is a script that crawls the web looking for forms and fills in whatever it finds.

FlyForms has four things standing in the way. Three of them are always on and you never configure them. The fourth is the one you choose.

The Challenge You Choose

Settings → Access has Ask respondents to prove they are human, and four cards to choose between.

No challenge is where every form starts. The always-on checks below still run.

Cloudflare Turnstile and Google reCAPTCHA are the two you have met on other people's websites. They work, and they belong to somebody else: choosing one means Cloudflare's or Google's code loads onto the page every visitor of yours opens. If you pick reCAPTCHA the screen warns you about a real problem — reCAPTCHA is known to misbehave on a custom domain. Turnstile does not.

FlyForms challenge is ours, and it is the interesting one.

The FlyForms Challenge, In Plain Words

Your respondent never sees it, never clicks a box, and never picks out the motorbikes. There is nothing to solve, and nothing to get wrong.

What happens is this. When the form loads, we hand the browser a small arithmetic problem — a number to find. There is no cleverness to it; the browser simply tries numbers until one works, roughly sixty-five thousand of them. That takes a fraction of a second on any phone made this decade, and the person filling the form in never notices, because it happens while they are reading the first question.

The point is not the difficulty. The point is the cost. A fraction of a second is nothing to one person. To somebody firing a hundred thousand submissions at your form, it is a real bill in electricity and time, and that is often enough to make them go and find an easier form somewhere else.

It needs no third party at all. Nothing is fetched from Google, nothing from Cloudflare, nothing from anybody. We measured a published form using it: zero requests to any third party. For a page that strangers open, that is worth something on its own — nobody is quietly watching your respondents on your behalf.

A challenge is good for an hour, and each one can only be used once, so an answer cannot be captured and replayed.

The Invisible Field

Every form carries a field that no person can see. It is positioned off the edge of the screen, hidden from screen readers, and skipped by the Tab key, so there is no way to fill it in by accident.

A crawler, which reads the page rather than looks at it, fills in every field it finds — including that one.

Anything arriving with that field filled is refused. The refusal says nothing about which check caught it, because telling somebody how they were caught is telling them what to change.

This one is always on and there is nothing to configure.

The Rate Limit

A single address may submit ten times a minute. Beyond that it is refused, and gets our own polite page — Too many attempts — rather than a wall of technical noise.

We measured it: twelve submissions fired as fast as they would go gave five accepted and then refusals for the rest.

Reading the form is limited too, at sixty times a minute, so a flood of page loads cannot be used to grind a form down either.

The Origin List

Settings → Access also has Sites allowed to embed this form — a list of the sites you are willing to have host your form. Leave it empty and any site may.

Fill it in and a submission arriving from a site that is not on the list is refused.

What This Does Not Stop, Honestly

Here is the part most products do not print.

Each of the checks above declines to fire when the thing it looks for is simply absent. A submission that carries no challenge is let through. A submission carrying no invisible field is let through. A submission with no site attached to it is let through.

Each of those has a good reason on its own, and the reason is the same reason every time: we would rather let something through than refuse a real person. Somebody on a locked-down browser, on an old phone, or with JavaScript switched off cannot produce a challenge answer. Refusing them would mean turning away a genuine respondent to catch a script — and a form that turns away real people has failed at the only thing it does.

But put those individually sensible decisions together and the consequence is this: a determined script that sends nothing but the answers, skipping all of the checks, is currently limited by the rate limit rather than blocked by the checks. Ten a minute, and no lower bound below that.

What does work, and we have measured all of it: a wrong challenge answer is refused, a filled invisible field is refused, and the rate limit refuses everything past the tenth in a minute.

This is a known open question, filed as Q-GAP-73, and it is being decided rather than ignored. The reason it is a decision and not a bug fix is that every way of closing it trades a real respondent on an unusual browser against a cheap script, and somebody has to choose the exchange rate.

Uploaded Files

Files are checked for type and size before anything is stored.

The type check reads the file itself rather than trusting what the browser says it is, because a browser says whatever it is told to say. The size ceiling is ten megabytes unless your plan sets a tighter one.

The name somebody's file arrived with is kept only as a label — the thing you read in the response. It is never used to decide where the file goes. The stored name is one we generate. A filename is written by a stranger, and a stranger's text should never be able to point at a place on a disk.

Files are not scanned for viruses today. That is worth knowing rather than assuming.

Some Other Things That Are Simply True

Every form is unlisted by default. Its address is twelve characters of random, and search engines are told not to list it. Anyone with the link can still open it — unlisted is not private, and the setting says so in as many words.

A wrong address tells nobody anything. Mistype a form's address and you get This form is not here — The link may be wrong, or the form may have been taken down. It does not say whether that address was ever real.

The same submission never becomes two responses. A double-tapped Submit, a retry after a bad connection, a refreshed tab: each carries the same identifier, and each lands as one row. You never see the same person twice for the same act.

Anonymous mode is not decoration. Turn on Collect nothing that identifies a respondent and there is nothing recorded to identify them — and their address is withheld even from the challenge provider, if you are using somebody else's. A promise made on the form is kept behind it.

Consent is recorded as it was worded. If you ask people to agree to something and later reword it, the responses you already have keep the wording those people actually agreed to.

A preview link expires. The link that lets you look at an unpublished form is signed and good for two hours, so it cannot be forwarded around indefinitely.